
Discovering treasure can be a life-changing experience, but it also raises a number of complex legal issues. The definition of “treasure” is regulated by law, and the rules surrounding its ownership and division may be unclear. In France, the concept of treasure is governed by articles 552 and 716 of the Civil Code, which provide the general rules applicable to the ownership of treasure.
A treasure is defined as an object or set of objects that are hidden or buried and discovered by chance, without the use of a map, metal detector, or systematic search. The treasure must not be able to be linked to a known or identifiable past or present owner. In the event of a fortuitous discovery, the treasure is divided between the owner of the land and the discoverer. If the discovery is made by several people, each of them is considered a discoverer.
Treasure Found in Basement
In July 2015, three workers in Indre-et-Loire discovered three plastic boxes containing 34 gold bars while breaking up a concrete slab in a basement. After agreeing with the landowner on the division of the treasure, the gold bars were sold for €1 million. Half of the proceeds went to the landowner, while each worker received €139,000, their employers €11,000, and another individual €66,000. However, the initial agreement was later contested by the lawyer of one of the workers, who held the shovel and had found the boxes in the rubble. The question arose: who was the true discoverer—the worker who broke the slab, the one who removed the rubble, or the one who opened the box?
The case went to trial, and in September 2017, the Blois Court of First Instance ruled that only two individuals were considered the discoverers: the worker with the jackhammer and the one who had removed the rubble with the shovel. The Court of Appeal upheld this decision, stating that “the discoverer of the treasure is the person who first made it visible.” The lawyer for the plaintiff argued that his client had scraped the concrete pieces and placed their hand on a box, making them the discoverer.
Complexity of Treasure Law
The law surrounding treasure is complex and has evolved over time. In 2017, the Court of Cassation settled a long-standing dispute over the discovery of a valuable 15th-century painting by Jean Malouel, hidden beneath another painting. The person who had advised the owner to have the painting cleaned, leading to the discovery of the Malouel painting, claimed to be a co-discoverer and sought a share of its value. However, the court ruled that the painting did not meet the legal definition of treasure, as it was inseparable from its physical support. The owner of the painting was therefore entitled to its full value, and the advisor was not considered a co-discoverer.
The court’s reasoning highlighted the legal complexity surrounding the definition of treasure: “Attended that, according to the terms of Article 716, paragraph 2, of the Civil Code, the treasure is any hidden or buried thing on which no one can justify ownership, and which is discovered purely by chance; that only things that are physically separable from the land in which they were found can receive this qualification and, as such, be subject to appropriation; that the judgment notes that Mr. [Z] acquired ownership of the litigious painted panel and that the work attributed to Jean Malouel was hidden under the visible paint; that it follows that this work is inseparable from its material support, the ownership of which is established in favor of Mr. [Z], so that it does not constitute a treasure within the meaning of the aforementioned text.”
In the case of the treasure discovered in Indre-et-Loire, the workers who found the gold bars were initially awarded a significant sum of money. However, the agreement was later contested, and the court ultimately ruled that the discoverer of the treasure was the person who first made it visible. They were the ones who removed the gravel and found the boxes, and thus they were considered the discoverer.